A Plea

The low point for me was when a neighbor had a sign stolen from her yard and posted about it in the security section of our neighborhood website. Fifty commenters chastised her for the name on that sign. They made fun of where she was from (another country). They asked how much she would pay to get the sign back if they had it in their garage.

The woman whose sign was stolen responded to the comments — upset she would likely see some of the commenters as she took her children trick or treating that night.

These were neighbors.

The ones we count on to watch our kid if we can’t beat the bus home. The ones who organize a food train for an ailing parent on a street. The ones who have a glass of wine together in the front yard on a balmy evening. The ones who give their kid’s hand me downs to the youngster up the street. The ones who show up to PTA meetings. The ones who teach Sunday school. The ones who pay their taxes and give to charity and sock money away for college and retirement.

We have turned on each other.

I’ve lost count of how many friendships met bitter ends on Facebook. Because you’re an idiot if you vote for him/her. Because you’re not the person I thought you were if you could vote for her/him. How could you? How dare you! There are many !!!!exclamation!!!! points and copious cursing and insults hurled with Herculean force. I’ve read comment threads that made my heart pound and my face turn red. My husband (who left Facebook months ago) has said to me, “Stop doing this to yourself.”

I can’t. I must be a witness to the end of civility. I can’t look away because I’m part of it.

I am so sad what has happened to us.

We have reduced each other to our vote. You may argue it’s okay to do so. This election matters!!!! Much is at stake!!!! The end is nigh!!!!!

Someone is going to be elected president tonight. Facebook will be electrified with hate and gloating and anger and despair — half celebrating, half despondent.

And then what?

Tomorrow will come and we will wake up and get our kids to school and go to work and at some point realize we didn’t thaw out the chicken for dinner.

In other words, life will go on.

In the 1980 election, my parents split their vote, one for Reagan and one for Carter. I only dragged the truth out of them a few years ago — who voted for whom. My father believed (and still does, which means mom told me) that one’s vote is a private decision based on your core values. Boy, do I miss those days.

It’s okay to be worried about the direction of our country, to fear that terrible things could happen if so-and-so is elected, but I can promise you we don’t feel this way because of what you posted on Facebook. There is no converting, only commiserating, and while it feels endorphin-rush good, I’ve also seen it devolve into screw-you bad.

Let’s accept we’re disappointed/deeply troubled/terrified by the other’s poor choice. Feel free to fret over what it says about their character. Pray for their sorry soul.

Then move the hell on.

The woman whose sign was stolen received some private message apologies from neighbors who said they reacted inappropriately. They were welcome band aids on a painful wound.

Neither candidate is going to invite my child over to play or talk me through a tough week or invite me to their Christmas open house.

After today, one thing remains certain — we are stuck with each other.

When my husband and I bicker, my secret weapon retort is, “Shoe’s on the other foot. How would you feel?”

For half of our country tonight, the shoe will be on the other foot.

Please think about that before you post.








Posted in Off the Air Tagged with: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
13 comments on “A Plea
  1. Tom Sangster says:

    Something I have worried about for years now. With the advent of social media civil discourse has gone out the window. Colleges are now firing professors for having different viewpoints than their students. Students are so thin skinned that they require “safe zones”, but only for themselves. No one else gets to feel safe. We have forgotten how to talk to each other. Now the media requires us to either be for or against whatever. There is no more middle ground. If I disagree with your viewpoint I simply will not allow you to express it. It is hard to argue with people when they say the end of days is here. We look and act nothing like what we should.

    • Jaye Watson says:

      Tom, well said. We don’t listen. We argue our point, then we wait for you to stop talking so we can continue to argue our point. I’m old enough to remember spirited debate..the kind without daggers and insults.

  2. Rocky Scott says:

    Yes Jaye, some things should be taken with a grain of salt. I found out what some of my neighbors thought of me , just by posting a sarcastic comment on FB, that was meant to be a joke. They are no longer friends on and off FB. reason is not automatic, those who deny it, cannot be conquered by it. I don’t think either of the candidates are worthy to run our country, IMO, but I did vote! In these days and times, I feel a sign in your yard is asking for trouble from the ( mad in crowd) whatever that means. Keep the good stories coming Jaye!!

  3. It is the absence of what our democracy has been proud of. We have peaceful elections and change of power. When hate and violence get in the mix, it can’t be good or right or American. I am holding my breath to see which side won the voters over. We have friends of both parties. Last round we agreed to disagree and didn’t get into politcal discussions. Obama won and life went on. We had to end a friendship last round because he didn’t understand one could be friends on other levels and agree to disagree on politics.

  4. Mark Wigginton says:

    this was so good, and timely.. As I plan my holidays and move on.

  5. Megan Lindsay says:

    Thank you, Jaye! I could hardly sleep last night because I’m so afraid of what’s going to happen today–not who will win the election, but how horribly people I love are going to treat one another in the aftermath. It’s hard to be silent on political issues, and sometimes I feel bullied into silence for fear of not being accepted by one group or another. It hurts like hell. And it’s an excellent reminder why it matters so much how I treat those I disagree with.

    • Jaye Watson says:

      Megan, thanks for writing. I’m with you on all fronts. Lack of sleep. Plenty of worry. Fear of what will happen. Thank you for reading.

  6. Cindy Simmons says:

    Perfect words for today. Thank you for Jaye.

  7. Noel McCullough says:

    Well said, thank you!

  8. Glenda says:

    Excellent post! I feel politics and religion are those topics that you can agree to disagree, and if your friendship is based solely and those two topics, then maybe it is time to move on. We are a team of the USA, but the ignorance of some divides the country. No one will agree with another 100%. Your beliefs are yours alone. Your choice. No explanation should have to be given period. Love over hate period. And always put yourself in that other shoe.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *